Anyone offering mobile communications, Wi-Fi, video compression or connected vehicles uses standard-essential patents. Holders must license on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms; implementers must show they are willing licensees. German courts and the UPC sharpened the rules again in 2026.
What we do
- Assessment of portfolios and essentiality
- Licence negotiations and pool licences
- Infringement actions and FRAND defence
- Security and counter-offers
- Competition law review and complaints
- Coordination of parallel proceedings worldwide
Legal framework
The framework was set by the CJEU in Huawei v ZTE (C-170/13). In January 2026 the Federal Court of Justice confirmed and refined its approach in FRAND-Einwand III (VoiceAge v HMD): the implementer must remain genuinely willing to take a licence throughout the negotiations.
At the UPC the Düsseldorf and Mannheim local divisions issued further FRAND decisions in 2026; in May 2026 Mannheim for the first time proposed a settlement with specific licence structures.
Parallel proceedings often run in the USA, the UK, China or Brazil, together with anti-suit injunctions. Coordinating the fora is a strategy in itself.
How we proceed
- Portfolio and claim analysis
- Negotiation and offers
- Enforcement or defence in court
- Licence or rate
Four cases from practice
Anonymised and simplified. Every case depends on its facts.
IoT manufacturer without a licence
A maker of connected meters received licence requests from several holders. We checked essentiality by sampling and negotiated a pool licence instead of many separate agreements.
Willingness documented
A device maker was sued. Because every step, counter-offer and security payment was properly documented, the FRAND defence succeeded.
Enforcement for a holder
A technology company enforced a video codec patent against an importer that had delayed negotiations for months.
Automotive supplier
It was unclear who in the supply chain had to take a licence. We negotiated an indemnity with the vehicle manufacturer and a separate licence for spare parts.
Frequently asked questions
What does willing licensee mean?
The implementer must clearly declare it wants a licence on FRAND terms and engage promptly and constructively in negotiations.
Do German courts set royalty rates?
Traditionally not. The UPC and some German chambers are now more open to rate-setting.
Is there an EU SEP regulation?
The Commission withdrew its proposal for an SEP regulation in 2025. The court-developed procedure applies.